New delivery model:
Integrated Project Insurance
Trial project:
Derby Silk Mill – Museum of Making: Case Study 3
Key Specific Objectives
- Completion in the spring of 2020 at a cost which is at or below the agreed target cost
- An exceptional and inspiring visitor experience in a high-quality environment
- Exhibition display and interpretation that creates 100% access to collections
- Exhibition displays that can evolve and be remade on-site to create new visitor experiences and stay relevant
- Flood mitigation successfully implemented
- High quality of design and materials in keeping with conservation requirements
Download pdf: Derby MoM Case Study 3
Stage at which first report will be published: | Kick off meeting | Brief / Team Engagement | Decision to Build | Build and Occupy |
Cost saving basis: | Investment Target | Challenging cost target | Agreed Target Cost | Outturn cost |
Daniel Defoe’s ‘A Tour thro’ the Whole Island of Great Britain’ (1724-27) records:
“This engine contains 26,586 Wheels, and 96,746 Movements, which work 73,726 yards of Silk-thread, every time the Waterwheel goes round, which it does three times in one Minute.”
Derby Museums:
How might we use the making of the Museum of Making, to engage people’s heads, hearts and hands – empowering them to be the creators, innovators and makers of the future?
The Museum of Making, extended & restored to life
Key facts
Project title | Derby Silk Mill – Museum of Making |
Client | Derby Museums |
Investment Target | £15.830m |
Initial Target Cost | £13.325m |
Form of project | Heritage extension and refurbishment |
Independent facilitation and risk assurance | IPInitiatives
Technical: BLP Financial: Artelia |
Alliance Members | Derby Museums
Bauman Lyons, architects Preston Barber, engineering GCA (UK) [replaced Adept], structural Speller Metcalfe, constructor Derry, building services Creative Core Ltd, exhibitions |
IPI Brokers | Griffiths & Armour |
Other Key Suppliers | Garvey: demolition and asbestos removal
Roger Bullivant: piling Adstone Construction: steel frame Façade & Glazing Solutions: curtain walling and glazing Swift Roofing Services: new roofing NRA Roofing: existing roof works Concrete Renovations: pillar restoration Independent Scaffold Services: scaffolding MSW Steel Decking UK: metal deck and concrete J&P Carpentry: carpentry MG Olympic: architectural metalwork
|
Executive summary
Derby Museums commissioned exhibition specialist Leach and architects Bauman Lyons with a design team to develop their vision for the Silk Mill as a “museum of making” for the 21st Century. Heritage Lottery and Arts Council funding was eventually secured, supplemented by funds from Derby City and local communities. Inevitably the brief for the extension and refurbishment project had developed into many various “success criteria”, and Bauman Lyons and Derby Museums decided that these could only be met by a fully collaborative “alliance” of designers, constructors and specialist contractors (including exhibition/digital specialists) appointed under the Integrated Project Insurance model
Case Study 1 described how arrangements were made to secure the acceptance of this transition by the existing consultants; how the new partners were selected; and how the alliance was formed, taking into account the hybrid “owner-controlled insurance” necessitated by the historic site.
Case Study 2 covered the progress of design, with BIM, the project culture and the alliance management and leadership, and how the gain/pain share and related insurance arrangements were concluded before work on site commenced.
This Case Study, the last in the series for this pilot project, starts by describing how the COVID 19 pandemic was addressed by the alliance, including how it affected progress. It then concentrates on the outcomes, both in terms of the finished product and also the time and cost of delivery. Success is not self-propagating unless it benefits both the client and the supply side, and insights from both are therefore also included.
The judges were particularly impressed with the project’s successful use of IPI, “blazing a trail for the themes in the government’s Construction Playbook”, with “a brave client adopting an innovative choice of procurement strategy, which has underpinned the delivery of fantastic results through true collaboration”.
To access case study 1&2:
Project summary
- 2012: Derby Museums established as an independent charity to manage sites and collections on behalf of Derby City, following closure of the Derby Industrial Museum
- 2013: creation of a prototype museum on the ground floor to test concept through an innovative “Re-make the Museum” process under public and stakeholder programme
- July 2014: Derby Museums awarded Arts Council England Major Partner Museums status
- May 2015: Heritage Lottery Fund Stage 1 approval for £9.4m
- January 2016: Arts Council England Capital funding Stage 1 approval for 2.58m, enabling 18-month development stage to begin
- March 2016: Appointment of core design team, including Leach exhibition specialists and Bauman Lyons architects who assisted Derby Museums with potential solutions which were sufficiently loosely defined to enable a fair OJEU process to follow
- May 2017: Planning submission with Conservation Plan; decision that the IPI model is to be used for this project and IPInitiatives engaged; OJEU Notice; Prequalification Questionnaire issued to applicant constructors and specialist contractors
- June 2017: RIBA Stage 3 Report: Design & Access Statement and Heritage Impact Statement; Stage 2 bid to Heritage Lottery Fund; Industry Day for bidders
- July 2017: Issue of Invitation to Tender to selected constructors and specialist contractors
- September 2017: Stage 2 Heritage Lottery Fund approval
- October 2017: Full alliance team appointed
- November 2017: Planning approval
- December 2017: Commercial alignment of alliance partners completed
- January 2018: Phase 1 design by alliance begins
- June 2018: Alliance contract (hybrid) agreed and signed
- July 2018: target completion for Phase 1
- October 2018: Inception of Owner Controlled Insurance policy for commencement of Phase 2, design development and construction
- December 2018: Late resolution of 25-year lease agreement with Derby City Council and wayleave agreement with Western Power
- January 2019: start of Phase 2
- May 2019: admission as a trial project under the Cabinet Office/Constructing Excellence Trial Projects Delivery Programme
- March – May 2020: stoppage of work due to Covid – 19
- December 2020: target completion (as extended due to wayleave issues and Covid -19)
- February 2021: actual final completion
Client objectives and vision
“There is a growing awareness in the construction sector that to improve performance key parties need to be brought together much earlier and relationships need to be significantly more collaborative. For the Museum of Making with our focus on co-operative working this is an essential transition and an innovative and new method of alliancing will suit our thinking. It is proposed therefore to use the Integrated Project Insurance (IPI) Model to deliver the project because it aligns the team’s interests and incentivises them to focus on outcomes which maximise the benefit for all stakeholders. This enables the whole team to work collaboratively under a single contract and insurance. The team form a Board under a new Alliance Contract and are incentivised to work together with all parties having a share in gain/pain that is linked to common not individual performance.”
Bauman Lyons, RIBA Stage 3 Report Rev1, June 2017
Vision
The aim was to create the Museum as a flexible, creative and inspirational hub with
technology and tools to build people’s skills, confidence and creative talent and to inspire the young creators and makers of tomorrow. The Arts & Heritage programme is to offer opportunities for audiences to participate in and enjoy contemporary art and design to creatively re-interpret the past, tell its many stories and respond to the sound of diverse voices.
Strategic Brief
The strategic brief was to create an inspirational new museum, revealing the whole building for the first time and re-introducing manufacturing to the site. It will celebrate Derby’s heritage of makers through the internationally, regionally and locally significant collections. It will create new co-working, maker and workshop spaces, with facilities for use by the makers of today and tomorrow. The project’s
overarching themes are STEAM-Powered (Science, Technology, Engineering, Arts and Maths), driven by the significance of the site, the building and the collections it contains; combined with the context of Derby and needs and motivations of local people, communities, businesses, organisations.
Success Criteria
“We have chosen the IPI model to reflect our values. Co-production and human-centred approaches are integral to the success of this project:
• Staged completion of building zones including workshop spaces at an early stage to support the build of fit out and exhibition
• Active involvement of volunteers and stakeholders in co-producing the Museum of Making
• Advocacy for new and diverse audiences
• Integrated programme of commissions for artists and makers
• Co-production and human-centred ethos, including openness to prototyping and the ability to respond proactively to change of circumstances and needs.”
–Derby Museums
The specific success criteria are numerous, falling under these headings:
Building and Exhibition: 24 No. Funders’ requirements:
- Heritage and Exhibition: 21
- People Skills: 14
- Local community: 23
Phase 2
Interruption by Covid – 19
In March 2020 the Government started to impose restrictions because of the growing impact of Covid-19 and to implement the Government’s social distancing recommendation, and the Construction Leadership Council published Site Operating Procedures, with the strong recommendation that these procedures be implemented by every operational construction site. The alliance board considered the options in close consultation with the subcontractors and suppliers working, or due to work, on site. The primary focus of the entire alliance to what was agreed to be a Review Event was to mitigate the delays and extra costs of the remaining activities as soon as the shutdown could be ended. The shutdown lasted 7 weeks; during this time the alliance made no assumption that extra funding would be available, and rather sought where significant savings could be made. The impact on the ongoing work within the constrained spaces of the Museum was monitored on an ongoing basis. Due to its cohesiveness and flexibility, the alliance gave a rapid response and agreed a target cost for the review event enabling the Heritage Lottery Fund to respond and agree additional funding – the only project to receive such a response.
Monitoring and control of costs
Refurbishment projects are notorious for cost escalation, especially where the buildings are of historic importance; the Silk Mill is at the extreme end of this spectrum. There were many stakeholders who contributed funding and whose wishes had to be respected. Derby Museums played an active part in the alliance’s deliberations throughout, and below are some of the issues which were accommodated:
- Floors: significantly more asbestos was found beyond that indicated by the survey. Instead of disturbing the ground floor to the Italian Mill, a new floor was created, saving some £170k and 8 weeks delay; also, testing, remediation, good architectural detailing and site control saved some £25k on the ground floor to the Civic Hall. Likewise load testing avoided removal of all internal floors as originally proposed, saving some £100k and 12 weeks delay.
- Rolls Royce engine: the original intention was to complete the build and install a rig hoist system to install the engine. The risks and costs of doing this were found to be extremely high: instead, the engine was flown over from America three months early to be installed, and the new Civic Hall was built around it.
- A full-time archaeologist was on site with trowel pits in various locations, around which the construction team had to work. One resulting challenge: the planned gas main route had to be diverted through the workshop to avoid disturbance.
- Flood mitigation: newly installed flood measures such as polished concrete floors and cement particle board cladding, together with a new flood alert strategy, resulted in only one day being lost to the programme despite two occasions of flooding during construction.
- The client-led co-production approach required coordinating museum staff and volunteers throughout live construction as well as supporting the museum recant. The project was re-programmed to hand over the workshop as a first element to create usable space for makers/volunteers.
- Enhanced AV display equipment was introduced as an invaluable asset to the Museum’s management plans.
- Use of refurbished furniture, more in keeping with the building.
The Rolls Royce jet engine, back airborne in Derby
Outcomes
Outcomes – quality
After nine years of initiation, consultation, prototyping, testing and sourcing the most experienced, determined and collaborative team through both procurement and behaviour workshops to deliver the construction, Derby Museums and their project stakeholders now have a conservation and restoration project of which they are truly proud, with 100% of the outlined client-led success criteria met or exceeded. In their own words:
“The project has breathed new life back into the building, revealing its scale and extent for the first time. The design of the new building was intended to reach 100% use of the existing structure, but the team delivered 110% by creating the additional floor. The look is modern with an industrial feel in quite a brutalist way with all fixtures and fittings repurposed from either the museum itself or further afield to ensure everything – including the building – is in its second use of life.”
“It has involved Derby people in the making of the museum through our active volunteer co-production programme with over 36,000 hours contributed to the project prior to lockdown, which was adapted to create remote volunteering opportunities with virtual meet-ups to reduce isolation. The Museum of Making creates access to 100% of our significant collections, provides an anchor for the city’s vision as a ‘City of Making’ (estimated to provide a gross economic impact of over £4.2m annually) and over 140,000 visitors a year will support Derby’s COVID recovery and help create new jobs. STEAM learning opportunities for schools, communities and visitors will help to continue the legacy of Derby’s heritage of ideas and innovation.”
Turning to the sustainability and upkeep of the facility, Derby Museums did not have CAD management facilities. The alliance created a 3D model (see below) in Navisworks Freedom, enabling free access for Derby Museums to the model. By clicking on a specific element it hyperlinks to the O&M manual to give detailed information.
Outcomes – time
The sequence of events affecting completion can be summarised into 3 elements:
(1) Delays in signing the 25-year Wayleave agreement by Derby City Council and Western Power: after mitigation this Review Event extended the Target Date by 4 weeks and the Transition Date by 3 weeks.
(2) Delays in grappling with unexpected events and difficulties which, under the Alliance Contract (unlike traditional contracts) fall to the Alliance to overcome: these were agreed to summate to 8 weeks’ delay.
(3) Covid and its constraints on working: after the initial shutdown of 7 weeks the ongoing impacts were actively mitigated and monitored on a rolling basis; in the absence of any other intervening causes of delay, the overall impact from this Review Event was agreed as 31.6 weeks.
As actual completion was 8 weeks after the extended Transition date, pain-share was incurred and shared by the Alliance Members in accordance with the formula and proportions in the Alliance Contract.
Outcomes – cost
The Target Cost, as updated to include the above two Review Events, was £14.413m; the Final Outturn Cost was £14,867m
The overspend against the investment target was therefore some 2.8% and was funded by pain-shares in the pre-agreed proportions: the Museum bearing £63k and the partners £391k.
The credit for this achievement should go to Derby Museums, all their partners and suppliers, and not least to the supportive response of the Heritage Lottery Fund when the project was hit by Covid at its most vulnerable stage.
Other participants’ observations
As part of the model’s culture of transparency – and to inform the Cabinet Office/CE Trial Project Programme – a four-hour feedback session was held “virtually” on 27 January 2021 with the entire alliance, including all suppliers.
The feedback was thorough and forthright, and the extracts below evidence (a) the participants’ generally positive experiences of IPI but also (b) the fact that the definition of roles and the dynamics of collaboration are still developing and far from optimal.
Pandemic – the ability to mobilise as a team when the lockdown happened and also think through a comprehensive approach to writing a proposal and prediction on cost/programme for the funders was a game-changer. We know from funders we were at least 6 months ahead of everyone else – and not everyone has had the success we have.
The alliance principles [Supportive, Teamwork, Ethical, Accountable and Makers] have been included in our order and subsequently in all the orders that have been placed by us. We believe that the STEAM acronym has been adhered to and has created a team spirit and relationship that is second to none, that any of us have experienced previously. We do however believe that the people involved in the project enable the principles to flourish and that careful consideration about who we engage with and who is involved in the project is the biggest contributor to the great relationship the project team has.
I think that collaborative working is driven by a quality team and strong leadership.
This was quite an easy one for us to answer; the way the IPI model is setup up relies on collaborative planning and working. The fact that there is one cost plan and we all have equal responsibility for the project promotes synergy throughout the team. The only caveat we would add to the above is that there were sub-contractors that we have interacted with on site that still acted in the sense of a traditional contract. However, it would be difficult to mitigate this 100%.
It was really hard sometimes and those who would claim not to have made mistakes are clearly too perfect for the rest of us! I think I remember Kevin Thomas and Louise Lado-Byrnes saying that good collaboration elsewhere is in spite of the process not because of it – I agree but on traditional projects it’s easy to be collaborative when things go well – it’s when they go wrong that IPI comes into its own.
Unlike any other project I’ve ever done, I do feel like I’ve really built this one. I haven’t just designed it and helped it being built by someone else: I really feel like mentally I’ve built it. I’ve been involved in all the issues about subcontractors on site and costings and everything. It does feel much more like a group of people have come together and have created something collegially.
There may be some confusion for those new to IPI as to how the Alliance Manager is not a Contract Administrator (or where the role is similar, where it is not) – possibly worth clarifying this in IPI literature to ensure bidders correctly put forward the most suitably qualified person and to explain how a ‘no Contract Administrator’ model contributes to a more collaborative environment.
However, the role should also address how decision making, quality and change control can still be rigorously monitored under IPI if there is no Contract Administrator. There were members of the team who were not sure exactly what the role of Alliance Manager was.
I think the Alliance Cost Manager is a really difficult role in the early days when nobody is listening to reports of cost overrun. We knew this project was going to be over budget 18 months ago – as Scott and Shona were telling us that – but no-one was really taking notice at that time.
The Derby Museum of Making alliance/project has topped the Constructing Excellence East Midlands Awards 2021 for Conservation & Regeneration, People Development, Innovation, Building Project of the Year and Winner of Winners. Also winner of Construction News’ 2021 Project of the Year (under £20m) Award, joint winner of Building’s Refurbishment Project of the Year Award, winner of IStructE’s award for. Best Renovation or Heritage Project and the Derby Historic Building Trust’s Architecture award for Reuse of a historic building, and winner of the Constructing Excellence National Award 2021 for Conservation & Regeneration.
Exhibition space 2nd floor
Hot desk office space
Exhibition space
Gallery
Guidance on the IPI Model
Guidance on the IPI Model is complementary to this case study, and is accessible at The Integrated Project Insurance (IPI) Model.
Of particular interest will be Section 9 which identifies the benefits the IPI Model is expected to bring for:
• The Client Group
• Lead Constructor/Project Manager/Design Consultants
• Specialist Contractors
• Other supply chain members
• Insurers
• Funders
• The Local Community
For change to take off and become “Business as Usual”, there must be seen to be benefits for all parties involved.
Miscellaneous
Authors
This case study has been developed for Constructing Excellence by Martin Davis, as IPI Mentor, with invaluable assistance from his IPInitiatives colleagues Kevin Thomas (the Independent Facilitator) and Louise Lado-Byrnes (the Alliance Manager), and the members of the Alliance.
All photographs and images are by kind permission of Speller Metcalfe.
Background: Trial Projects programme
The Government Construction Strategy aims to change the relationship between clients and the entire supply chain within the industry. The trial projects perform a central role in delivering the Strategy’s sustainable reduction in costs and have been testing three new procurement models (Cost- Led Procurement; Integrated Project Insurance; Two Stage Open Book) that were proposed by industry and developed by a joint task group. Case study reports are therefore an output of monitoring the progress and outcomes of the trial projects.
They are produced at four stages: Kick-off Meeting; Brief/Term Engagement; Decision to Build; Build and Occupy. Other case study reports can be found at:
https://constructingexcellence.org.uk/cabinet-office- trial-projects/
Project contacts
For further information on Insurance Backed Alliancing under the IPI model or to introduce a potential trial project, please contact Martin Davis, IPI Mentor for the Cabinet Office, at [email protected] or Kevin Thomas at [email protected] or Louise Lado-Byrnes at louise.lado- [email protected]
Successful applicants who are accepted onto the Cabinet Office’s Trial Projects Delivery Programme will then have access to the latest versions of the Procurement documentation and system, Alliance Contract, Supplier Alliance Subcontract and IPI Policy.
29 January 2022
Get involved
Constructing Excellence welcomes all organisations that share our values and mission. Get in touch to find out how your organisation can become part of the UK’s leading movement for change devoted to delivering excellence in the built environment.
Email: [email protected]
I was recommended this website by mmy cousin. I’m not sure whether this post is written by him as nobody else know suych detailed aboyt
my problem. You are incredible! Thanks! https://Lvivforum.pp.ua/
I savour, lead to I found exactly what I used to be looking for. You’ve ended my 4 day lengthy hunt! God Bless you man. Have a great day. Bye
I don’t think the title of your article matches the content lol. Just kidding, mainly because I had some doubts after reading the article.
erectyle disfunction: canadiandrugsgate – best online canadian pharmacy
amoxicillin for sale http://clomidrexpharm.com/# where can i buy clomid pills
Priligy tablets dapoxetine price priligy maxpharm
by prednisone w not prescription: raypharm – prednisone 60 mg
dapoxetine online: priligy – Priligy tablets
cost of amoxicillin 875 mg http://amoxilcompharm.com/# amoxicillin 500 mg tablet price
prednisone pill: ray pharm – prednisone 20mg capsule
can i get cheap clomid without rx order cheap clomid without prescription can i buy cheap clomid tablets
amoxicillin tablet 500mg: Com Pharm – amoxicillin without rx
order amoxicillin uk https://prednisoneraypharm.com/# how to purchase prednisone online
where can i get cheap clomid pill: clomid rex pharm – can you get cheap clomid without rx
buy amoxicillin over the counter uk: com pharm – amoxicillin buy canada
amoxicillin brand name amoxicillin 500 mg purchase without prescription how to buy amoxicillin online
can i purchase cheap clomid no prescription: clomid – where buy clomid without dr prescription
amoxicillin in india https://prednisoneraypharm.com/# prednisone 5 50mg tablet price
buy dapoxetine online: cheap priligy – priligy maxpharm
where can i buy clomid no prescription generic clomid get cheap clomid
get generic clomid price: clomid online – order generic clomid prices
buy prednisone online australia: order Prednisone – where can i buy prednisone
buy generic clomid without insurance: rex pharm – can you get generic clomid pills
max pharm: dapoxetine online – priligy max pharm
where can i buy prednisone online without a prescription: raypharm – prednisone 2.5 mg daily
buy amoxicillin online no prescription: Com Pharm – buy cheap amoxicillin
medicine amoxicillin 500mg: amoxicillin 500mg capsule – prescription for amoxicillin
buy priligy max pharm: priligy max pharm – Priligy tablets
can you buy clomid without dr prescription: rexpharm – can i buy generic clomid no prescription
amoxicillin capsules 250mg: Com Pharm – amoxicillin no prescription
priligy maxpharm: priligy maxpharm – dapoxetine online
medication from mexico pharmacy http://mexicanpharmgate.com/ buying prescription drugs in mexico online
cheapest Lisinopril: buy Lisinopril 1st – buy Lisinopril online
http://plavixclo.com/# buy Clopidogrel over the counter
cheapest Lisinopril lisinopril1st lisinopril pills
mexico drug stores pharmacies http://mexicanpharmgate.com/ mexican mail order pharmacies
antibiotic amoxicillin: amoxil – buy amoxicillin over the counter uk
cheapest Lisinopril: lisinopril 2.5 mg for sale – buy Lisinopril 1st
prednisone 5443: order Prednisone – medicine prednisone 10mg
buy cytotec over the counter Abortion pills online Misoprostol 200 mg buy online
lisinopril1st: lisinopril1st – Lisinopril 1st
http://plavixclo.com/# п»їplavix generic
priligy maxpharm: priligy maxpharm – dapoxetine online
buy Clopidogrel over the counter: buy Plavix Clo – antiplatelet drug
plavix best price PlavixClo Best Price antiplatelet drug
http://lisinopril1st.com/# buy Lisinopril 1st
prednisone brand name us: generic Prednisone – over the counter prednisone cream
buy cytotec: buy cytotec online – purchase cytotec
prednisone over the counter australia: generic Prednisone – prednisone 10 mg tablet
https://plavixclo.com/# buy Clopidogrel over the counter
buy misoprostol over the counter: buy cytotec online – buy cytotec in usa
dapoxetine price: cheap priligy – max pharm
пин ап казино: pinup kazi – пин ап казино
vavada kazi vavada kazi вавада онлайн казино
vavada-kazi.ru: vavada-kazi.ru – вавада казино
http://vavada-kazi.ru/# вавада онлайн казино
pinup kazi: пин ап зеркало – пин ап вход
vavada kazi: vavada kazi – vavada kazi
пин ап казино: пин ап казино – pin up казино
пинап казино: пин ап казино официальный сайт – пин ап вход
pin up казино пинап казино pinup kazi
вавада: vavada kazi – vavada
https://vavada-kazi.ru/# вавада
pinup: pin up казино – pinup-kazi.kz
pinup kazi: pinup – пин ап зеркало
вавада казино: вавада онлайн казино – vavada-kazi.ru
pinup kazi: пинап казино – пин ап казино
пин ап зеркало пин ап зеркало пин ап казино официальный сайт
https://pinup-kazi.ru/# пин ап вход
pin up казино: пин ап казино – pinup kazi
вавада: vavada – vavada
vavada: вавада казино зеркало – вавада казино онлайн
пин ап казино: pin up казино – pinup
pinup-kazi.ru: пинап казино – pinup-kazi.ru
пин ап казино официальный сайт пин ап зеркало pinup kazi
best ed pills at gnc: canada pharmacy online – male dysfunction treatment
can ed be reversed https://indianpharmstar.com/# mail order pharmacy india
mexican pharmaceuticals online: mexican pharmacy – buying prescription drugs in mexico
mexico pharmacies prescription drugs: mexicanpharmeasy.com – mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa
buying from online mexican pharmacy mexican pharm easy reputable mexican pharmacies online
best ed medicine: canadian pharm – the canadian drugstore
pet meds without vet prescription: canadian pharmacy – pet meds without vet prescription canada
natural cures for ed canadianpharm1st soma therapy ed
ed in men: canadian pharmacy – buy medication online
mexican rx online: mexican pharmacy – buying prescription drugs in mexico
mexican rx online: MexicanPharmEasy – mexico drug stores pharmacies
ed cures https://mexicanpharmeasy.com/# buying prescription drugs in mexico
online pharmacy india: indian pharmacy – mail order pharmacy india
medication from mexico pharmacy mexican pharmacy mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa
medicine erectile dysfunction: canadianpharm1st.com – how to overcome ed naturally
prescription drugs canada buy online: canadianpharm1st – real viagra without a doctor prescription
best online pharmacy india: indian pharm – india online pharmacy
treatment of ed http://mexicanpharmeasy.com/# mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs
pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa Mexican Pharm medicine in mexico pharmacies
mexican mail order pharmacies: Pharm Easy – buying prescription drugs in mexico
over the counter ed treatment https://mexicanpharmeasy.com/# mexico pharmacies prescription drugs
buy generic ed pills online: canadian pharm – treat ed
mexico pharmacies prescription drugs MexicanPharmEasy mexican rx online
foods for ed: canadianpharm1st.com – home remedies for ed
mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa: mexicanpharmeasy.com – mexican rx online
best ed pills https://indianpharmstar.com/# indianpharmacy com
ambien without a doctor’s prescription canadianpharm1st is it illegal to buy prescription drugs online
top online pharmacy india: IndianPharmStar – top 10 pharmacies in india
purple pharmacy mexico price list: Pharm Easy – buying prescription drugs in mexico online
mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa: Pharm Easy – mexican drugstore online
cheapest online pharmacy india: IndianPharmStar – best online pharmacy india
indian pharmacy paypal indian pharmacy buy medicines online in india
ed meds online without prescription or membership: canadianpharm1st.com – ed clinic
drugs for ed http://mexicanpharmeasy.com/# mexico pharmacies prescription drugs
india pharmacy mail order: indian pharm – top 10 pharmacies in india
mexican mail order pharmacies mexicanpharmeasy.com buying from online mexican pharmacy
ed treatments: canadian pharmacy – cheap erectile dysfunction
http://semaglutidepharm.com/# rybelsus
AmoxilPharm: AmoxilPharm – amoxicillin 500 coupon
semaglutide pharm: rybelsus price – Buy semaglutide pills
Paxlovid over the counter п»їpaxlovid Paxlovid.ink
http://ivermectinpharm.store/# Ivermectin Pharm
cheap Rybelsus 14 mg: rybelsus generic – Buy semaglutide pills
amoxicillin generic: Amoxil Pharm Store – amoxicillin buy no prescription
generic gabapentin: over the counter neurontin – neurontin 100mg tablet
http://gabapentinpharm.com/# cost of neurontin 600mg
neurontin: Gabapentin Pharm – Gabapentin Pharm
neurontin price comparison: neurontin 400 – Gabapentin Pharm
http://gabapentinpharm.com/# neurontin 100mg price
Buy compounded semaglutide online semaglutide pharm rybelsus generic
paxlovid for sale: Paxlovid.ink – Paxlovid.ink
cheap Rybelsus 14 mg: Semaglutide pharmacy price – Buy compounded semaglutide online
http://paxlovid.ink/# paxlovid price
neurontin 300 mg price in india: Gabapentin Pharm – Gabapentin Pharm
amoxicillin without a prescription: buy cheap amoxicillin – AmoxilPharm
http://ivermectinpharm.store/# Ivermectin Pharm
Gabapentin Pharm: Gabapentin Pharm – neurontin without prescription
Amoxil Pharm Store: AmoxilPharm – AmoxilPharm
https://ivermectinpharm.store/# ivermectin 0.08
Ivermectin Pharm: Ivermectin Pharm – stromectol 6 mg dosage
neurontin 50mg cost: Gabapentin Pharm – Gabapentin Pharm
minocycline for sinus infection stromectol 6 mg tablet Ivermectin Pharm
https://paxlovid.ink/# paxlovid india
purchase cytotec: purchase cytotec – buy cytotec
https://ciprofloxacin.cheap/# cipro 500mg best prices
cipro for sale buy ciprofloxacin over the counter where to buy cipro online
lisinopril with out prescription: zestril 20 – medication lisinopril 10 mg
https://ciprofloxacin.cheap/# buy generic ciprofloxacin
lisinopril 20mg india: lisinopril 40 mg pill – zestoretic 25
buy misoprostol over the counter cytotec online purchase cytotec
https://azithromycinus.com/# how to get zithromax online
purchase lisinopril: lisinopril 20 mg price without prescription – lisinopril 10mg
how to buy generic clomid without rx how to get cheap clomid without insurance cheap clomid without prescription
buy cipro online: buy generic ciprofloxacin – where can i buy cipro online
zithromax prescription: zithromax 500 mg lowest price pharmacy online – average cost of generic zithromax
http://ciprofloxacin.cheap/# where to buy cipro online
can you get generic clomid without dr prescription: can you get generic clomid for sale – cheap clomid pill
order zithromax without prescription: zithromax generic price – cost of generic zithromax
https://clomid.store/# where can i buy cheap clomid pill
lisinopril pill 20mg zestoretic online lisinopril price uk
https://cytotec.top/# buy cytotec over the counter
buy cytotec pills: Cytotec 200mcg price – cytotec pills buy online
purchase cipro п»їcipro generic ciprofloxacin 500 mg tablet price
lisinopril 10 mg coupon: ordering lisinopril without a prescription – lisinopril 10 mg on line prescription
http://cytotec.top/# buy cytotec pills online cheap
zithromax without prescription: buy zithromax without presc – buy zithromax online australia
lisinopril 5 mg buy online can you buy lisinopril over the counter buy lisinopril 5mg
clomid pills: order generic clomid tablets – can you buy cheap clomid now
http://clomid.store/# where to get clomid without rx
order generic clomid: can you get clomid without dr prescription – order clomid without dr prescription
cipro ciprofloxacin: ciprofloxacin 500mg buy online – buy cipro without rx
where can i purchase zithromax online where can i purchase zithromax online zithromax 500 mg lowest price online
zithromax cost australia: zithromax 250 mg – zithromax for sale 500 mg
buy lisinopril without a prescription: buy lisinopril 20 mg online united states – lisinopril 25 mg
buy cipro no rx buy cipro online usa ciprofloxacin over the counter
cytotec abortion pill: buy misoprostol over the counter – cytotec pills buy online
http://azithromycinus.com/# zithromax 500 without prescription
generic zithromax over the counter: buy cheap generic zithromax – where can you buy zithromax
can you buy zithromax over the counter zithromax over the counter average cost of generic zithromax
generic lisinopril 10 mg: order lisinopril without a prescription – lisinopril tabs 88mg
https://lisinoprilus.com/# 25 mg lisinopril
lisinopril 12.5 mg: lisinopril 10 mg best price – lisinopril brand name in usa
zithromax buy online no prescription: zithromax 500 tablet – zithromax 500 mg
buy cytotec buy cytotec pills online cheap buy cytotec in usa
https://ciprofloxacin.cheap/# where to buy cipro online
ciprofloxacin over the counter: buy ciprofloxacin – ciprofloxacin generic price
cost generic clomid without dr prescription cost of generic clomid price where to buy clomid without prescription
https://clomid.store/# buying clomid without prescription
cytotec abortion pill cytotec buy online usa buy cytotec pills
order lisinopril 20mg: lisinopril cost 40 mg – cheap lisinopril no prescription
https://ciprofloxacin.cheap/# ciprofloxacin 500 mg tablet price
http://kamagra.men/# Kamagra Oral Jelly
https://cenforce.icu/# buy cenforce
best ed medicine: drugs1st – viagra without a doctor prescription
non prescription ed drugs drugs1st drugs1st
https://semaglutidetablets.store/# semaglutide best price
Cenforce 100mg tablets for sale: Cenforce 150 mg online – order cenforce
https://kamagra.men/# buy kamagra online usa
http://cenforce.icu/# cenforce.icu
over the counter ed treatment: buy ed pills online – viagra vs cialis bodybuilding
cheapest cenforce: Cenforce 150 mg online – Buy Cenforce 100mg Online
https://cenforce.icu/# Purchase Cenforce Online
http://drugs1st.pro/# natural ed treatment
https://semaglutidetablets.store/# buy rybelsus online
online ed medication: cheapest ed treatment – where to buy erectile dysfunction pills
https://cenforce.icu/# cenforce
order cenforce: cheapest cenforce – cenforce for sale
https://semaglutidetablets.store/# buy rybelsus online
erectile dysfunction medicine online where to buy erectile dysfunction pills ed meds on line
Kamagra tablets: п»їkamagra – buy kamagra online usa
https://edpills.men/# top rated ed pills
https://edpills.men/# online erectile dysfunction pills
https://cenforce.icu/# Buy Cenforce 100mg Online
ed medications cost: cheap ed pills online – cheap ed pills
http://cenforce.icu/# Cenforce 100mg tablets for sale
https://casinositeleri2025.pro/# 100 tl bonus veren bahis siteleri
en cok kazand?ran slot oyunlar? slot oyunlar? puf noktalar? slot oyunlar? puf noktalar?
http://casinositeleri2025.pro/# en gГјvenilir bahis siteleri
пин ап вход: пин ап – pinup 2025
kayД±t bonusu veren casino siteleri: bonus veren siteler yeni – iddaa siteleri
https://slottr.top/# slot oyunlar? puf noktalar?
yeni gГјncel deneme bonusu veren siteler deneme bonusu beren siteler casino oyna
bet siteleri bonus: canli oyun – gГјvenilir bahis siteleri 2025
http://pinup2025.com/# пин ап
en gГјvenilir yatД±rД±m siteleri: en gГјvenilir bahis siteleri – gГјvenilir kripto para siteleri
pinup 2025 пин ап зеркало пин ап казино официальный сайт
http://slottr.top/# en cok kazand?ran slot oyunlar?
en iyi casino oyunlarД±: curacao lisans siteleri – bilinmeyen bahis siteleri
http://slottr.top/# slot oyunlar?
пин ап вход пин ап казино pinup 2025
pinup 2025: пин ап вход – пин ап казино официальный сайт
http://slottr.top/# slot siteleri
en gГјvenilir site: en iyi bahis sitesi hangisi – deneme bonusu veren siteler 2025
http://slottr.top/# az parayla cok kazandiran slot oyunlar?
slot oyunlar? puf noktalar? slot siteleri slot tr online
http://casinositeleri2025.pro/# date sitesi
casino deneme bonusu veren bahis siteleri: betboo plus – casД±no
http://pinup2025.com/# пин ап казино официальный сайт
en kazancl? slot oyunlar? az parayla cok kazandiran slot oyunlar? slot siteleri
yeni siteler: deneme bonusu veren bahis siteleri 2025 – cazinomaxi
пин ап казино: пин ап казино зеркало – пин ап казино
http://slottr.top/# slot oyunlar? puf noktalar?
https://slottr.top/# slot siteleri
en kaliteli bahis siteleri vaycasino deneme bonusu veren siteler 2025
пин ап казино: пин ап зеркало – пин ап казино официальный сайт
http://pinup2025.com/# пин ап казино официальный сайт
gГјvenilir kumar siteleri: deneme bonusu veren slot siteleri 2025 – canlД± oyunlar
https://slottr.top/# slot oyunlar? puf noktalar?
https://casinositeleri2025.pro/# by casino
slot siteleri slot oyunlar? puf noktalar? slot oyunlar? puf noktalar?
como bakery yorumlarД±: son bahis giriЕџ – en iyi casino sitesi
http://casinositeleri2025.pro/# en iyi deneme bonusu veren siteler
en kazancl? slot oyunlar? en cok kazand?ran slot oyunlar? slot siteleri
slot oyunlar?: slot tr online – slot tr online
https://slottr.top/# slot oyunlar?
pinup 2025: пин ап казино зеркало – pinup2025.com
https://casinositeleri2025.pro/# bonus veren yasal siteler
https://casinositeleri2025.pro/# bet gГјncel giriЕџ
en kazancl? slot oyunlar? en kazancl? slot oyunlar? slot siteleri
gГјvenilir oyun siteleri: bet oyun siteleri – vidobet giriЕџ
https://casinositeleri2025.pro/# deneme+bonusu+yeni
http://pinup2025.com/# пинап казино
http://slottr.top/# slot tr online
en kazancl? slot oyunlar?: slot siteleri – en kazancl? slot oyunlar?
http://slottr.top/# slot tr online
en cok kazand?ran slot oyunlar? en cok kazand?ran slot oyunlar? slot oyunlar? puf noktalar?
en cok kazand?ran slot oyunlar?: en kazancl? slot oyunlar? – az parayla cok kazandiran slot oyunlar?
пин ап: пин ап зеркало – пин ап казино официальный сайт
http://canadianpharmi.com/# online meds for ed
top 10 online pharmacy in india indiapharmi Online medicine home delivery
https://mexicanpharmi.com/# mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs
india online pharmacy: Indian online pharmacy ship to USA – indian pharmacy
https://mexicanpharmi.com/# reputable mexican pharmacies online
reputable indian online pharmacy: Indian online pharmacy ship to USA – п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india
best online pharmacies in mexico mexican pharmacy mexican rx online
http://mexicanpharmi.com/# buying prescription drugs in mexico
http://mexicanpharmi.com/# buying prescription drugs in mexico online
mexico drug stores pharmacies: Mexican pharmacy ship to usa – reputable mexican pharmacies online
http://indiapharmi.com/# buy prescription drugs from india
purple pharmacy mexico price list: Cheapest online pharmacy – buying from online mexican pharmacy
treat ed canadian pharmacy dysfunction erectile
http://mexicanpharmi.com/# mexican pharmaceuticals online
http://canadianpharmi.com/# ed treatment
ed treatment: canadian pharmacy – cheap medications online
canadian drug pharmacy canadianpharmi errectile disfunction
http://canadianpharmi.com/# buy prescription drugs without doctor
https://canadianpharmi.com/# ed medicines
new erectile dysfunction treatment: Canada Pharmacy – prescription drugs
http://mexicanpharmi.com/# best online pharmacies in mexico
how to treat ed: canadian pharmacy – cheap online pharmacy
erectile dysfunction drug Best Canadian pharmacy buy prescription drugs online
http://indiapharmi.com/# п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india
https://mexicanpharmi.com/# mexico drug stores pharmacies
purple pharmacy mexico price list: Purple pharmacy online ordering – medication from mexico pharmacy
mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa: Online Mexican pharmacy – mexican pharmaceuticals online
п»їbest mexican online pharmacies Best online Mexican pharmacy mexico drug stores pharmacies
https://canadianpharmi.com/# ed cures that actually work
https://mexicanpharmi.com/# mexico drug stores pharmacies
purple pharmacy mexico price list: Best online Mexican pharmacy – purple pharmacy mexico price list
https://indiapharmi.com/# india pharmacy mail order
http://canadianpharmi.com/# buy ed pills online
india pharmacy mail order: Online medicine home delivery – online pharmacy india
http://prednibest.com/# prednisone 60 mg
how to get generic clomid price clomidonpharm buy generic clomid without insurance
http://prednibest.com/# prednisone price canada
where can i buy generic clomid without insurance: clomid on pharm – order generic clomid without rx
https://prednibest.com/# buy prednisone 10mg online
amoxicillin 875 mg tablet: amoxicillin without a doctors prescription – amoxicillin 250 mg
where to buy cheap clomid clomid on pharm where to get generic clomid online
https://amoxstar.com/# amoxicillin buy online canada
http://prednibest.com/# prednisone 54
order prednisone online no prescription: PredniBest – cost of prednisone 10mg tablets
buying amoxicillin in mexico AmoxStar amoxicillin 500 mg
https://cipharmdelivery.com/# cipro pharmacy
https://cipharmdelivery.com/# buy cipro online without prescription
where can i buy clomid without insurance cost of clomid pill can i get clomid price
https://cipharmdelivery.com/# buy cipro online canada
prednisone 1 tablet: prednisone buy cheap – cheap prednisone online
http://prednibest.com/# prednisone 80 mg daily
ciprofloxacin order online: purchase cipro – purchase cipro
https://amoxstar.com/# canadian pharmacy amoxicillin
where buy cheap clomid without dr prescription where buy generic clomid no prescription where can i buy clomid pills
http://cipharmdelivery.com/# buy cipro without rx
amoxicillin capsules 250mg: AmoxStar – how to get amoxicillin
amoxicillin 500 mg tablet price: 875 mg amoxicillin cost – amoxicillin 500 mg without a prescription
https://clomidonpharm.com/# cheap clomid for sale
buy prednisone 10mg by prednisone w not prescription prednisone uk price
can you buy generic clomid price: can you buy clomid without prescription – get generic clomid tablets
http://amoxstar.com/# amoxicillin pills 500 mg
where to get amoxicillin over the counter AmoxStar amoxicillin 500 mg tablet price
order cheap clomid now: can you get generic clomid prices – can you get cheap clomid
buy prednisone canada: Predni Best – prednisone 2 mg
http://cipharmdelivery.com/# buy cipro without rx
cipro online no prescription in the usa ci pharm delivery purchase cipro
https://clomidonpharm.com/# can i order clomid online
ampicillin amoxicillin: Amox Star – over the counter amoxicillin
buy cipro online canada: ciprofloxacin generic – buy cipro cheap
https://clomidonpharm.com/# can you get cheap clomid online
can i get cheap clomid without prescription where can i buy clomid without rx where to buy generic clomid pill
ciprofloxacin mail online: ciprofloxacin generic price – buy cipro without rx
https://prednibest.com/# prednisone 10mg prices
prednisone 20 mg tablets PredniBest buying prednisone from canada
prednisone pill 10 mg: PredniBest – prednisone brand name
amoxicillin no prescipion: buy amoxicillin over the counter uk – amoxicillin 1000 mg capsule
https://amoxstar.com/# amoxicillin online without prescription
ciprofloxacin order online CiPharmDelivery buy cipro without rx
ciprofloxacin 500mg buy online: where to buy cipro online – ciprofloxacin 500 mg tablet price
cost of amoxicillin: AmoxStar – buy amoxicillin
http://amoxstar.com/# generic amoxicillin over the counter
prednisone rx coupon PredniBest apo prednisone
prednisone: prednisone 20mg tab price – prednisone canada
http://clomidonpharm.com/# how to get generic clomid pill
amoxicillin 500mg no prescription Amox Star amoxicillin 875 mg tablet
buy amoxicillin online no prescription: amoxicillin 500mg buy online canada – amoxicillin tablet 500mg
buy cipro cheap: buy cipro online canada – cipro online no prescription in the usa
amoxicillin tablet 500mg Amox Star amoxicillin 250 mg price in india
http://prednibest.com/# prednisone 50 mg tablet canada
buy ciprofloxacin over the counter: buy cipro – where can i buy cipro online
https://prednibest.com/# can i order prednisone